When a dead Englisch man is found in the supply shed behind Christina Brubacher's business, she begins her own investigation into the crime. Surprisingly, her helper is none other than Noah Zimmerman, her long-time crush.

As romance blooms, Christina's life as a nursery and shop owner quickly turns topsy-turvy because of the secret sleuthing that might cause problems for her and Noah in their Old Order Mennonite community. But they are in too deep to back out-even if it means risking their own lives to catch a murderer and help an Englischer.