Days after Corey's breakup, a photo of her ex wrapped in the arms of another woman goes viral on Facebook. Confronted with this gleeful boast about "happily ever after," Corey, a forty-something-year-old lesbian, decides that she can't live in a state of perpetual loneliness, plagued with the burden of her own failure in finding happiness and love.

Armed with her meticulously crafted checklist, Corey embarks on a mission to heal, move on, and find "the one." But no matter how many items she checks off her list, or how faithfully she follows the sage wisdom of psychics, her breakup coach, and the legendary rapper Eminem, her hope in finding her one true love begins to fade away--until she's suddenly torn between two.

Now, with her heart unexpectedly on the line, Corey must find out what she really wants--and where her true happiness lies.