In September, 1962, two 18-year-old freshmen at Brown University named Bob Waxler and David Beckman first crossed paths. They quickly discovered they had a lot in common, especially an abiding fascination with language, literature, and the life of art. Four years later, as college seniors, they collaborated on a small book of poems, which brought them a flurry of attention, then faded into memory as the two friends began separate life journeys-Bob becoming a professor of literature at a Massachusetts college, David working as an advertising and promotion writer in New York with sidelines as a poet, playwright, and actor.
In 2014, an article in the Brown alumni journal rekindled their connection. It sparked an exchange of emails that gradually blossomed into this book-an extended dialogue between two old friends on poetry, life, the passage of time, and the power of the written word.
In You Say, I Say, Waxler and Beckman trade observations, opinions, questions, and arguments about the ways in which literature transforms, challenges, disturbs, and inspires us. Spurred by lifetimes largely dedicated to "deep reading," they debate the meaning and value of works ranging from Dante's Inferno and Shakespeare's King Lear to Tolstoy's Death of Ivan Ilych; the poems of Wordsworth, Blake, Coleridge, and Keats; and the works of T.S. Eliot, Kafka, Beckett and Joyce. They often uncover new and surprising facets of classic works in the glare of post-modern experience. And they even exchange a couple of new poems-their own work-triggering reflections on the creative process and its many unexpected twists.
Along the way, Waxler and Beckman delve into questions that have haunted generations of readers and critics. And they reveal, directly and indirectly, how encounters with literature have shaped their intellects and their lives.
In a world increasingly dominated by visual and electronic noise, You Say, I Say captures the enduring power of literature-not to resolve the great questions of human existence, but to help us explore those questions in ways that are eye-opening, life-changing, and profound.
"You Say, I Say is a joy and privilege to read. Two college friends, decades later, exchange letters about what matters most: family, friendship, the history of literature from Homer to Kafka. I am deeply grateful to able to follow the exchange-to learn from them as they learn from each other. The book is a testament to how literature-and the questions literature allows us to ask-sustains us."-Josh Kotin, Associate Professor of English and Director of the Graduate Program, Princeton University
"Bob Waxler's and David Beckman's new book proves that the quest for meaning does not end with graduation. Their conversation makes a refreshing book and proves how well curiosity can age."-James Marlow, author of Charles Dickens: Uses of Time
"The authors' reflections, threaded into the fabric of memoir, create a narrative path that will draw readers in to contemplate the significance of friendship, of ideas, of language, and of the literary imagination."-Martha C. Pennington, Visiting Professor of English Language and Applied Linguistics at the University of Reading (UK)
"The writing is superb . . . which comes as no surprise. David Beckman and I worked together for years in the magazine business, and his writing was always thoughtful and wonderfully creative. Now he and Bob Waxler have combined to create a grand example of their prodigious skill."-Jim Hayes, Publisher Emeritus, Discover and Fortune magazines
"In their heartfelt and engaging literary conversation, You Say, I Say, Waxler and Beckman find meaning in quiet corners while chaos reigns around us. They unearth gems of philosophy, battle their private demons, and share their love of reading and writing, giving us hope that literature, language, and friendship can indeed keep us alive."-Jean Trounstine, professor, activist, co-founder of the women's branch of Changing Lives Through Literature, and author of eight books, including Sounds Like Trouble to Me (Running Wild Pub, 2026)
"You Say, I Say offers an engaging and intense conversation where we participate in an unfolding process of resisting conclusions so that we can join two fine minds exploring their capacities to deepen the activity of reflection-examining presuppositions, constantly questioning what could serve as answers."-Charles Altieri, Professor Emeritus, University of California at Berkeley
"In these letters between two old college friends who happen to be writers, we feel their joy in rediscovering each other after many years while we contemplate the far-ranging questions they pose. It is a gift that the memories these friends shared brought them together again to write to each other and, it turns out, to us."-Katherine Hastings, Poet Laureate Emerita of Sonoma County