"[This book] should be marked as a valuable addition to Lincoln studies. . . . Burlingame's masterly editing has transformed the original 'history' written by Nicolay and Hay to the more appropriate status of a primary document."--Richard Hall, H-CivWar
"A distinguished editor and biographer . . . Burlingame displays his usual sensitivity to male relationships . . . there are gems to be found even in this brief distillation."--Michael Chesson, Civil War Book Review
"This is emphatically a work of homage as well as of scholarship, both monumental in its function and its size. . . . [this book] turns up little gems of information about Lincoln not available elsewhere."--Adam I.P. Smith, Journal of the Abraham Lincoln Association
"[This book] leaves its final result as what we most need--a nearness to the actual truth of the life and life-lore of possibly America's and the world's greatest man."--Ray B. Browne, The Journal of American Culture
"To those who view every primary source on Lincoln as something precious, Burlingame has once again provided a valuable service."--Michael Burkhimer, The Lincoln Herald
"Burlingame's work provides Lincoln students with a first-hand look at the early years of the Lincoln administration. Readers who decide to tackle this small work will be well rewarded."--Bruce Tap, Journal of Illinois History