". . . . an authentic look and feel with spare, yet effective contours and relatable characters and problems." --Matt White, Publishers Weekly
"This is a wonderfully well-rounded, character-driven story about fairness and self-interest. Lonergan's black inking and colorless illustrations seem simple but are packed with raw emotion that's evident in every face and expression. This is an amazing book that both teens and adults will love--definitely a home run." --Peter Blenski, Booklist
"References to Mark McGwire, President Clinton, and Monica Lewinsky explore society at the time and provide a backdrop for Carl's confusion. The b&w illustrations are simple and appealing, often focusing on characters' faces to express the tone. Some sexual references and mature situations make this a choice for older teens [...] Recommended." --Elizabeth Andersen, Library Media Connection