Young widow Amelia Stauffer loves her serene life caring for her three daughters along with widower Ryan Miller's two little girls, weaving baskets, and baking treats to sell at her friend's store. Her peace is shattered, though, when various possessions disappear and an unknown person prowls her property at night.

Ryan Miller thinks of Amelia as much more than his children's babysitter, but he and Amelia belong to different groups of Mennonites making a relationship impossible. Will they find a way to bridge that gap while working together to identify and stop the intruder?