This final novel from the deceased Peet, completed by Rosoff, is a not-quite-YA, not-quite-adult historical fiction story of hardship after hardship...The book itself is incredibly ambitious, as was Rosoff's task of finishing it. Beck is a passive character in his own life, but in the moments when he pushes himself to take action, readers will finally get some satisfaction. A heartbreaking, painful work that gives hope to the restorative power of true human connection.
--School Library Journal (starred review)

Characters' dialogue is often rendered in earthy regional dialects, while the narrative prose is brilliantly evocative and precise, producing a sweepingly epic physical and emotional journey. Heartbreaking, hopeful, and inspired.
--Kirkus Reviews (starred review)

Whether a hardened heart can--or should--leave itself vulnerable to love is brilliantly explored in this powerful, vividly told, beautifully written collaboration.
--Shelf Awareness for Readers (starred review)

Peet's posthumous novel, completed by Rosoff, follows Beck from his meager beginnings in early twentieth-century England to his harrowing first days in Canada...older teens and adults who appreciate literary historical fiction might find plenty to appreciate in this story of a hard-won discovery of redemption and home.
--Booklist

This book tackles big issues: racism, sexual abuse by clergy members, poverty, and examines the effects of childhood trauma on developing adults. The plot is driven by Beck's need for security and acceptance, and his traumatic past influences the brooding tone of the novel. A well-written work on a difficult topic, this book would be best introduced with a trigger warning.
--School Library Connection

Some of the harshest episodes of Beck's life are captured in passages of stunning grace, typical of the late Peet's writing.
--Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books

Readers will feel Beck's torture, both physical and emotional; they will experience his physical hardships but also rejoice when he discovers true love. Beck will be enjoyed by Peet's fans, as well as lovers of historical fiction and adventure.
--VOYA

From the very first pages it's clear we are in the hands of a master storyteller (or two; as explained in an appended note, Rosoff finished the novel after Peet's death). The vibrancy, earthiness, and originality of the prose is startling; the spot-on dialogue adds to the immediacy; secondary characters are vividly portrayed. There are no wasted words; no too-lengthy descriptive passages, yet somehow we see, smell, experience everything.
--The Horn Book

Not since A Monster Calls, the novel Patrick Ness wrote based on a story idea from the late Siobhan Dowd, has a collaboration from two of my favorite authors felt so bittersweet. But Beck, Mal Peet's posthumously published novel finished by his friend Meg Rosoff, comes close.
--BookPage

Peet and Rosoff use such poignant and stark language...In the end, it's a love story; not about how two people fall in love, but how one person -- despite hardship -- can finally feel worthy and open enough to accept love.
--Globe and Mail

The writing is to be savored in this life-affirming novel about the resilience of the human spirit.
--Buffalo News

An epic story set in the 1920s and '30s for erudite, mature readers.
--Boston Globe

...exquisitely written novel.
--People