2004 Maryland Children's Book Award Master List

"The colorful illustrations are rendered in acrylic and resemble finger painting. Changes in the text size add to the visual effect and aid in reading the story aloud. Children will enjoy seeing how self-sufficient and confident Carlin becomes because of his expedition."--School Library Journal

"The bright acrylics and humorous details (Carlin is a comical sight decked out in armor and carrying his raft) soften the scary bits and also add some fun. This is a satisfying example of how facing fears helps to conquer them."--Booklist

"The well-conceived art--bold, vibrant acrylics--capture Carlin's fear and hope, his friends' complicity and concern, and finally his determination and triumph."--Kirkus Reviews

"With Bravery Soup, Cocca-Leffler, who has written and/or illustrated more than 30 books for children, may have created a classic. I think so. The awards will come, but, more important, children will be reading this story or having it read to them for many, many years."--The Telegraph of Nashua

"Carlin accepts the challenge with great trepidation, but is soon surprised to find out that he really had nothing to fear and that there was much to learn by taking a chance. The wonderful illustrations bring to life Carlin's emotions and the many stages in his journey. The book has a delightful feel to go along with its warm-hearted message."--Children's Literature