
Reader Score
87%
87% of readers
recommend this book
Critic Reviews
Great
Based on 5 reviews on


INSTANT #1 NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER
A December 2018 Indie Next Pick
One of Kirkus Reviews' Best of 2018 Picks
BookPage Best of the Year 2018
A LibraryReads Pick for November 2018
A LibraryReads Hall of Fame Winner
Washington Post's 10 Books to Read This November
One of PopSugar's Best Fall Books to Curl Up With
One of Publishers Weekly Booksellers' Favorite 25 Titles of the Year in 2018
"Penny pulls together an insightful plot that weaves in family feuds, clandestine investigations, undercover cops and a loving look at Three Pines." --Oline Cogdill, South Florida Sun Sentinel "Louise Penny's novels are unique for how seamlessly they straddle the line between charmingly small-town mysteries and big-city police procedurals . . . It's not to be missed!" --BookPage (Top Pick) "It's hard to see how Louise Penny can raise the stakes any further for her iconic, fatherly good guy, Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, but somehow in each book she does." --News & Observer "Brain-teasing puzzles, life-and-death stakes and lots of Three Pines, a magical place where the warmth in the villagers' hearts thaws the ice on their eyelashes."--St. Louis Post Dispatch "Complex ongoing saga... Wait anxiously for the next installment."--Pittsburgh Post-Gazette "Penny does a splendid job of interweaving those three main plot lines, studding them with several life-threatening scenes that had me holding my breath, and building to a wild finale."--Tampa Bay Tribune "Nimble sleight-of-hand plotting, strong characters, profound compassion and luminous prose are hallmarks of Penny's novels. Although darker than previous books, this new entry is no exception."--Seattle Times