"Geary's archly antiquated drawing style is ideally suited for bringing bygone eras to vivid, convincing life. Geary's exacting, historically accurate approach makes this--as well as his other nonfiction works--a natural for true-crime fans as well as comics lovers." --Booklist
"Outstanding! A-" --Onion
"A great series of books and this latest was fascinating. What I love about this book and in truth all of Geary's books in this series is his fair minded telling of the tale. While he may lead the reader towards a solution he leaves it to the reader to draw conclusions from the facts as we know them." --www.CrimeSpreeMag.com
"[Rick Geary] uses his detached style to get at something essential in the story he's telling, contrasting his placid portraiture with the roiling passions just under the surface." --www.AVClub.com
"Another gem, even though it's not as famous a crime as some others in the series. This double-murder of an adulterous couple set suburban New Brunswick, N.J., all atwitter with saucy speculation in 1922--and it has the same effect today." --Minneapolis Star Tribune (August 30, 2012)
"Geary's black-and-white art is precise without being clinical, and at times it approaches the cinematic, using dramatic angles and sharp juxtapositions to communicate the queasy mystery of this double homicide." --Joe Sutliff Sanders, Teacher Librarian