Critic Reviews
Mixed
Based on 3 reviews on
From 1907 to 1967, a network of reservoirs and aqueducts was built across more than one million acres in upstate New York, including Greene, Delaware, Sullivan, and Ulster Counties. This feat of engineering served to meet New York City's ever-increasing need for water, sustaining its inhabitants and cementing it as a center of industry. West of the Hudson, it meant that twenty-six villages, with their farms, forest lands, orchards, and quarries, were bought for a fraction of their value, demolished, and submerged, profoundly altering ecosystems in ways we will never fully appreciate.
This paradox of victory and loss is at the heart of Nineteen Reservoirs, Lucy Sante's meticulous account of how New York City secured its seemingly limitless fresh water supply, and why it cannot be taken for granted. In inimitable form, Sante plumbs the historical record to surface forgotten archives, bringing lost places back to life on the page. Her immaculately calibrated sensitivity honors both perspectives on New York City's reservoir system and helps us understand the full import of its creation.
An essential history of the New York City region that will reverberate far beyond it, Nineteen Reservoirs examines universal divisions in our resources and priorities--between urban and rural, rich and poor, human needs and animal habitats. This is an unmissable account of triumph, tragedy, and unintended consequences.
"Sante writes with the verve we expect from her, transmitting an astounding amount of rapid-fire details and facts with delectable prose that keeps it humming and makes it easy reading."
Founded in 1914, The New Republic is a magazine of interpretation and opinion for a rapidly changing world.
In contrast to more exhaustive accounts of New York City’s water system, Lucy Sante’s “Nineteen Reservoirs” is a meditation, a forensic accounting of the damage the reservoir system did and how it still resonates, @RESullivanJr writes. https://t.co/PdFxoNtTMv
The only academic institution devoted to advancing scholarly and public understanding of New York City's rich and living past
Today on Gotham, Gerard Koeppel reviews Lucy Sante's book Nineteen Reservoirs: On Their Creation and the Promise of Water for New York City. @experimentbooks Making Book on the Rez: A Hundred Years of Watershed Inquietude https://t.co/1PsKFCGhIO