When W. B. "Bill" Camp, a giant cotton and potato grower, presided over its burning in downtown Bakersfield, he declared: "We are angry, not because we were attacked but because we were attacked by a book obscene in the extreme sense of the word." But Gretchen Knief, the Kern County librarian, bravely fought back. "If that book is banned today, what book will be banned tomorrow?"
Obscene in the Extreme serves as a window into an extraordinary time of upheaval in America -- a time when, as Steinbeck put it, there seemed to be "a revolution . . . going on."
"Booklist," September 15, 2008
"This case study of an attempt to censor John Steinbeck's "Grapes of Wrath" exposes the wrongheadedness of censorship in a way that more theoretical arguments often fail to do... This is a skillfully written, passionate book... Wartzman has really done his homework, and he tells the story dramatically, using character and dialogue to propel the narrative."
"Metro Newspaper," September 24, 2008
"An important and illuminating new book."
"
Salinas Californian," October 4, 2008
"A fast-paced narrative.... Enlightening and well worth reading."
"Columbia Journalism Review," November/December 2008 issue
""Obscene in the Extreme" is much more than a conventional book-banning saga. It richly chronicles one of the epic tales of the 1930s, the struggle between left and right, hired hands and big farmers, migrant Okies and natives, in the towns and fields of California.... Unfailingly fair to all, Wartzman brings to life a rich cast, ranging from the radical journalist Carey McWilliams to the farm works chosen by his employers to burn a copy of "The Grapes of Wrath" on the streets."
"Minneapolis Star-Tribune," November 30, 2008
"With a novelist's skill and journalist's acumen, Wartzman uses the incident [of the book ban] as a springboard to explore the context of those turbulent times, the personalities and motivations of those involved and the notion of censorship as a politicalweapon."
"Boston Globe," December 2, 2008
"Well-researched, readable.... It's a cautionary tale, particularly relevant in light of the vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin, who once allegedly asked the librarian in her own small town of Wasilla, Alaska, whether censorship was all right."