Deeply engaging and richly illustrated...A must-read for anyone interested in the history of al-Andalus and its enduring hold on the imagination of Arab and Muslim artists and thinkers in the Middle East, North Africa, Europe, and beyond. One great benefit of this text is Calderwood's eschewing the methodological nationalism that marks most scholarship on al-Andalus...Instead, he traces themes that cut across national borders to suggest pan-regional and, one could argue, global imagined communities for whom al-Andalus has been, and often remains, a touchstone of authenticity, a well-spring of inspiration, and a beacon of hope for possible futures.--Jonathan Shannon "International Journal of Middle East Studies" (2/12/2024 12:00:00 AM)
Combines mediaeval, cultural, memory and literary studies to explore the 'afterlife' of al-Andalus in the centuries since it was lost...[this book's] great strength lies in the varied and rich body of sources Calderwood consults - literature, art, architecture, film, music, exhibitions and academic works, composed in an impressive range of styles and languages, from eighth-century Arabian poetry to twenty-first-century rap - in order to explore different distinct legacies of al-Andalus.--Jen Pearce "Literature & History" (5/21/2024 12:00:00 AM)
It is refreshing to read [this] presentation of the many ways in which the cultural narrative of al-Andalus is used to perform a diverse array of identities and worldviews throughout the world, as a counter to the xenophobic embrace by Spain's far-right Vox party of a Reconquista cultural narrative that relies upon a reductive flattening of the Muslim Other. Calderwood's challenge to conventional academic treatments of al-Andalus is to change focus, away from history and historiography and towards present-day human beings that engage with some version of an al-Andalus narrative to confront, negotiate, and overcome the challenges faced in their communities.--Rob Bayliss "Comedia Performance" (4/18/2024 12:00:00 AM)
With extraordinary linguistic range, Calderwood brings us the voices of Arabs and Muslims who have turned to the distant past of Spain to imagine their future. Rather than dismissing al-Andalus as a confused heap of notions or narrowing its vision to Romantic utopianism, Calderwood turns to the subjunctive mood, the mood of what might be, to argue for the future of al-Andalus as time and place ahead of us with infinite capacity.--Hussein Fancy, Yale University
Calderwood shows that al-Andalus has been deployed effectively across this wide range of contexts to engage in debates about Arab and Berber identities in the Middle East and North Africa, to articulate a feminism autochthonous to the Muslim world, to reflect on the loss of a Palestinian homeland, and to explain musical productions and to motivate collaborations across different traditions, languages, and cultures.--Elizabeth Spragins "Public Books" (11/29/2023 12:00:00 AM)
An incredibly meticulous scholarly work that is impressive both in its breadth and its readability...The deftness with which Calderwood pivots between works from the nineteenth century to the twenty-first, from poetry and fiction to television and film, is wonderful. [The author] has gathered and analyzed an impressive range of material that clearly and brilliantly makes the case for the many lives al-Andalus has, and continues to live.--Alexander E. Elinson "Journal of North African Studies" (2/26/2024 12:00:00 AM)
In this beautifully conceived and deftly written book, Calderwood brings to light a rich range of sources, many previously unavailable in English, Spanish, or French translation. On Earth or in Poems provides interpretations that are innovative, insightful, and useful for scholars and students of medieval Spain, as well as of contemporary Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East.--David A. Wacks, University of Oregon
A timely intervention in medieval studies and contemporary cultural studies alike, Calderwood's book exemplifies the best work being done in the expanding field of global medievalism.--S. J. Pearce, New York University
Offers an original and insightful study of how medieval Muslim Spain or al-Andalus continues to signify in multiple ways for modern scholars and artists and their audiences...in this study Calderwood goes in a new and fascinating direction, analyzing how the notion of al-Andalus itself is adopted and transformed by modern authors, artists and communities who seek to express something about the contemporary world and their place in it.--Michelle M. Hamilton "Hespéris-Tamuda" (6/30/2024 12:00:00 AM)
A compelling contribution to the study of this particular neo-medievalism...offers a fresh focus on the community identities that are part of the twentieth- and twenty-first-century symbolic motif of al-Andalus...a novel and thought-provoking approach.--Christina Civantos "Journal of Arabic Literature" (10/17/2024 12:00:00 AM)
A decisive contribution to contemporary scholarship on the Andalusi legacy...This work is an essential resource for scholars of cultural memory, historiography, postcolonial studies, and the political uses of the past.--Ahlam El Haddad "Confluence" (8/14/2025 12:00:00 AM)