"Alternating the narration between Anne and Delia from 1946 through 1949, Zeldis vividly portrays the postwar period as it follows the women from Vassar to Paris to Palestine and back. Each woman has a different relationship to her Judaism, and through family upheaval and romantic entanglements, each grows into a new appreciation for her religion and her sense of self. Historical-fiction book groups will find much to discuss here." - Booklist
"[A] nuanced story of friendship and heritage . . . . Zeldis adds depth to the brisk story in her portrayal of the characters' complex feelings about their Jewish heritage. It's an appealing historical." - Publishers Weekly
"Zeld-is . . . has con-struct-ed an intri-cate plot with echoes of Gentleman's Agree-ment, Lau-ra Z. Hobson's 1947 best-selling nov-el about "gen-teel" anti-semitism in Amer-i-ca, and Exo-dus, Leon Uris's block-buster about the found-ing of the state of Israel that came out about a decade later. At its heart, though, One of Them is a com-ing-of-age sto-ry." - Jewish Book Council
"Zeldis explores a friendship between two students at Vassar College just after World War II . . . . The milestones of first loves, the agony of family secrets, and a hunger to find their place in the world guide each woman in a different direction until the fitting and satisfying ending. VERDICT A strong story of women's friendship set against a dynamic historical era. The journey Anne and Delia undertake will inspire plenty of fruitful book club discussions." - Library Journal
"Absorbing . . . . Kitty Zeldis captures period details, like fashion, with precision." - Hadassah Magazine
"One of Them is a thoughtful chronicle of growth and friendship, and an examination of several facets of Jewish identity . . . . Kitty Zeldis's insightful third novel explores the complexities of Jewish identity through the lives of two young women who meet at Vassar College." - Shelf Awareness
"This novel, set in the late years and aftermath of WWII provides insights into how two Vassar sophomores--both Jewish--navigate the fraught times and their circumstances . . . . Their difficulties and challenges are carefully described in this fascinating story of two women finding out who they are after WWII." - The Paris Insider
"This is a profound and compelling read for anyone who appreciates character-driven stories and a rich historical backdrop. The emotional weight of Anne and Delia's journey will stay with you long after you've finished the final page. Check this book out!" - MSN.com
"The contrast between how Anne and Delia own their Jewish identities, and how Anne eventually comes to terms with hers is portrayed with deep understanding. Each woman's journey is tangled with their histories, upbringings, tragedies, and mistakes, creating two very distinct characters who meld together perfectly. . . . . the story of friendship and the hope of happiness given both characters at the end feels completely satisfying. This book feels particularly timely." - Historical Novels Society
"[Anne and Delia's story is] inspiring and a testament to the importance of forgiveness and being true to one's self. Multifaceted protagonists, an intriguing plot and beautiful writing make this a novel not to miss." - Bookreporter.com
"One of Them showcases secrets and betrayals along with efforts to make amends." - Novels Alive
"So many issues are explored in this novel as each woman follows her path to maturity, making discoveries and adjustments that will alter the course of their lives. Kitty Zeldis['s] . . . prolific writing has turned her into a marvelously effective storyteller with a unique perspective on her characters. Her depictions of names and places at Vassar College were exactly right, although the college has changed since I graduated in 1971. Even then it had changed since 1947. This is a book for anyone who's betrayed a friend, had a crisis of conscience, or reevaluated her choices in life." - Hooked on Books, Writer Advice
"Kitty Zeldis, a pseudonym, has written several novels that explore antisemitism, including Not Our Kind and The Dressmakers of Prospect Park. However, One of Them stands out as particularly timely, published during a period when college campuses are grappling with investigations and resignations related to antisemitism. The novel delves into how this type of discrimination not only damages institutions but also has a profoundly hurtful impact on personal relationships. While attention often focuses on demonstrations and marches, Zeldis emphasizes that the most effective response can sometimes be as simple as standing up for a friend." - Woman Around Town
"An enthralling portrait of a woman daring to defy convention in the face of rigid social confines. Lively period details of the bustling city breathe life into Not Our Kind, a story capturing issues of discrimination, the marginalization of women and class disparities. Often veering in unexpected directions, the novel is filled with thought-provoking turns that explore timely subjects in a gripping light. . . . The book's greatest strength is exploring how the building of relationships can help dissolve ignorance. . . . its themes linger long after the final page is read." - USA Today on Not Our Kind
"A richly layered assimilation story set in post-WWII Manhattan . . . chapters that alternate between Patricia's and Eleanor's point of view enable these co-protagonists to be defined by more than their stance on a Jewish question that's both urgent and on the wane in the post-WWII era. . . . an historical novel that resonates in contemporary Trumpian America. . . . A very good novel." - Washington Independent Review of Books on Not Our Kind
"The Dressmakers of Prospect Heights is a page-turner about dreams dashed and rediscovered, secrets kept and revealed, and the redemptive power of love. The three women at the core of this unforgettable journey--from early 20th century Russia and New Orleans to 1920s New York, and from loneliness to belonging--will work their way into your heart." - Meg Waite Clayton, bestselling author of The Postmistress of Paris and The Last Train to London, on The Dressmakers of Prospect Heights
"The Dressmakers of Prospect Heights by Kitty Zeldis is gripping historical fiction at its very best. Three women whose lives are bound by a secret history are forced to make irreversible choices in order to survive. Moving from nineteenth-century Russia to the brothels of New Orleans in 1910, and landing in New York City in the 1920s, Zeldis doesn't miss a beat. She weaves an exquisite tale filled with love, loss, despair, and forgiveness, as her richly developed characters tackle the difficult decisions one must make and the repercussions of those that are made for you." - Lisa Barr, New York Times bestselling author of Woman on Fire, on The Dressmakers of Prospect Heights
"One of Them is one of my favorite books this year. The narrative is electrifying, completely engaging, and one heck of an emotional ride. I don't know if Zeldis thought of School Ties while writing this novel, but I did as a reader. I loved the narrative arc of both Anne and Delia. The way they interacted and grew is nothing short of perfect. The smartest thing that Zeldis did was to make their potential romantic partners part of the story, not the whole of it. Do I recommend it? Absolutely. It may be on my Best Books of 2025." - WriterGurlNY