Matthew has returned to his Amish hometown in Lancaster after eschewing the lifestyle for the Englisch world. He is now a divorced single dad and has given up on women.

Ironically, Claire has returned to Lancaster herself. She, like Matthew, had left the town for the Englisch world. Now she is back, single and taking a teaching job. Matthew's son enrolls in her class and he finds himself immediately attracted to Claire even though he doesn't want to get involved. Claire finds Matthew attractive as well but he soon finds out that isn't her only secret. Can the two come back to their Amish town and find the love they both always wanted?