Reid has an enjoyable writing style... he also tackled areas of scholarly dispute head-on, outlining rather than glossing over key controversies' -- "Current Archaology Magazine"
a new and thought-provoking history of Roman Scotland by an acclaimed expert' -- "Edinburgh Life"
"[A] comprehensive, accessible, and thought-provoking study..."-- "Scotland on Sunday"
"...offers thought-provoking re-assessments of the loss of the IXth Legion, the reasons for building Hadrian's Wall, and why at least four Roman emperors personally visited the edge of the empire."-- "Southern Reporter"
[A] comprehensive, accessible and thought-provoking study'--David Robinson "The Scotsman"
"Superbly researched, accessibly written and thoughtfully and convincingly argued, this book presents a chronological history of the Romans in Scotland."--Ken Lussey "Undiscovered Scotland"
"A new detailed history of Roman Scotland, offer[ing] an opportunity to re-examine the legend."-- "West Highland Free Press"
"...sifts through the evidence for the impact of the Romans on the country that would become Scotland... [S]heds new life on brutal conflict."-- "Sunday Post"
It is comprehensive in its coverage, beautifully written and illustrated and something that will attract many non-specialist readers as well as the historians and archaeologists with an interest in the period'-- "Scottish Archaeological Journal"
Provides a new and highly original narrative of Scotland's Roman past. Original, because of its less Roman-centered synthesis of three centuries of Roman-indigenous interaction ... I can warmly recommend this well-readable publication to those interested in the history of Roman Scotland, or - more generally - in the comparative study of Roman frontiers'--Nico Roymans, Emeritus Professor of West European Archaeology, VU University Amsterdam
A brilliant book - seamlessly combining history and archaeology to shine new light on Roman Scotland'--Professor Alice Roberts