Critic Reviews
Good
Based on 3 reviews on
A Foreign Affairs Best Book of 2022
"Valuable . . . offers many lessons for Western policy makers today."--Paul Kennedy, Wall Street Journal
"The lessons are sobering."--The Economist
Economic sanctions dominate the landscape of world politics today. First developed in the early twentieth century as a way of exploiting the flows of globalization to defend liberal internationalism, their appeal is that they function as an alternative to war. This view, however, ignores the dark paradox at their core: designed to prevent war, economic sanctions are modeled on devastating techniques of warfare.
Tracing the use of economic sanctions from the blockades of World War I to the policing of colonial empires and the interwar confrontation with fascism, Nicholas Mulder uses extensive archival research in a political, economic, legal, and military history that reveals how a coercive wartime tool was adopted as an instrument of peacekeeping by the League of Nations. This timely study casts an overdue light on why sanctions are widely considered a form of war, and why their unintended consequences are so tremendous.
"… it provides an assessment of how successful sanctions are in preventing military aggression. The book was fortuitously timed. It came out mere weeks before Russia invaded Ukraine and thereby became the target of a whole host of sanctions from the west."
Exploring the American idea through ambitious, essential reporting and storytelling. Of no party or clique since 1857. https://t.co/uHeZCz8ahz
Nicholas Mulder, the author of a new book on the history of sanctions, talks to @AnnieLowrey about how to make sense of the West’s use of the “economic weapon” against Russia. https://t.co/fZv3CovSVA
Founded in 1914, The New Republic is a magazine of interpretation and opinion for a rapidly changing world.
“Today, economic sanctions are generally regarded as an alternative to war, but for most people in the interwar period, the economic weapon was the very essence of total war,” writes Nicholas Mulder in his new book “The Economic Weapon.” https://t.co/77CRfGiltQ
"Lucidly written, scholarly and thought-provoking."--Gideon Rachman, Financial Times
"Mulder . . . looks at sanctions over the three decades after the First World War--and reaches unsettling conclusions. . . . The lessons are sobering."--The Economist
"Mulder charts how the rise of economic sanctions and blockade during the interwar years, as a tool to enforce peace, drove the autarkic policies of Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan, ultimately destabilising the international system rather than fortifying it."--Robin Harding, Financial Times
"Mulder argues in his impeccably well-researched and, because of its timeliness, gripping book that 'sanctions did not stop political and economic disintegration but accelerated it' in the interwar period. . . . Mulder's book provides an uncomfortable warning that while sanctions have sometimes worked, they have also been contentious, ineffective and counterproductive."--Emma Duncan, The Times
"This revelatory history of 'economic warfare'--blockades and sanctions--reminds us that up to 400,000 people died of blockade-induced malnutrition in Central Europe in the First World War, plus 500,000 in the Ottoman Middle East. You will look at twentieth-century history with fresh eyes."--Noel Malcolm, Daily Telegraph, "Perfect Holiday Reads"
"A fortuitously timed history of the use of economic sanctions during the interwar period of the 20th century. Their mixed success cautions against hoping that the West's sanctions against Russia can bring about an end to war in Ukraine."--The Economist, "Best Books of 2022"
A Foreign Affairs Best Book of 2022
"As Nicholas Mulder shows in The Economic Weapon, a much longer history lies behind the invention of modern sanctions."--Tom Stevenson, London Review of Books
"A fascinating new book. . . . Taken as a superbly researched work of history, it lights up key aspects of the twentieth century in a deeply thought-provoking way."--Noel Malcolm, Daily Telegraph
"Original and persuasive analysis. . . . For those who see economic sanctions as a relatively mild way of expressing displeasure at a country's behavior, this book, charting how they first emerged as a potential coercive instrument during the first decades of the twentieth century, will come as something of a revelation."--Lawrence D. Freedman, Foreign Affairs
"[A] superb study of sanctions during the interwar era. . . . Mulder's fascinating story weaves together politics, economics and law [and] provides invaluable insight into the experience of sanctions one hundred years ago."--Max Harris, Times Literary Supplement
"Terrifyingly relevant."--Rogé Karma, New York Times's "The Ezra Klein Show"
"Illuminating."--Chris Miller, American Purpose
"A highly relevant book."--Lars Erik Schönander, National Interest
"Brilliantly researched."--Pavlos Roufos, The Jacobin
"Nicholas Mulder has succeeded admirably here in rescuing the historical origins of sanctions from relative obscurity. . . . Mulder's thoroughly researched and intelligent assessment of the history of sanctions should be required reading for anyone contemplating Russia's new aggression."--Richard Overy, Journal of Strategic Studies
Winner of the Stuart L. Bernath Book Prize for best first book by the Society for Historians of American Foreign Relations (SHAFR)
"The Economic Weapon is a superb account of the history of sanctions, and their profound impact on international politics. Although sanctions were once heralded as a force for peace, Mulder shows they often fail and sometimes make war more likely or even produce a humanitarian nightmare.&rdquot;--John Mearsheimer, author of The Great Delusion: Liberal Dreams and International Realities
"This is a tour de force of historical research and argument. With great subtlety and richness, Nicholas Mulder transforms our understanding of twentieth-century global and international history."--David Edgerton, King's College London
"Mulder reveals the history of liberalism's ultimate weapon. An essential contribution both to scholarship and to the present-day debate on economic sanctions."--Adam Tooze, author of Shutdown: How Covid Shook the World's Economy