While the title may hint at The Great Gatsby and its charismatic protagonist, the keenly self-aware book has much stronger connections to classic British coming-of-age novels such as Dodie Smith's I Capture the Castle, wherein the affectionate, sharply observed family characterization and the atmosphere play roles as large as any romantic element. . . . There's enough tension here that readers may hope for a ramp-up into full thriller, but the story moves toward a different kind of satisfying conclusion, with victory lying in an unpredictable tennis match and the ability to preserve the possibilities of future summers.
--Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books (starred review)

A London teen recounts the summer that tore the family apart... Through the narrator's keen observations, made more poignant in hindsight and through sarcasm, readers view the twisting and turning development of Kit's manipulation. Although slim, Rosoff's taut, psychological story elicits a slow burn, leaving readers wondering how far and wide Kit's power will extend through the family. It's all just the beginning of the narrator's loss of innocence. A searing coming-of-age novel.
--Kirkus Reviews

Through an unnamed, ungendered teen's sharp eye and knowing narration, Printz Medalist Rosoff tells a dryly humorous story of summer and love gone awry. . . Between Mal and Hope's wedding planning, the Godden brothers' tensions, and Kit's erratic attentions, the summer darkens, leading this effective character study and depiction of childhood's end to a surprising climax.
--Publishers Weekly

Meg Rosoff's The Great Godden is a first-rate coming-of-age novel told by an astute and appealing unnamed narrator over the course of one uncharacteristically fraught seaside summer. . . . The Great Godden is filled with equal parts drama and reflection, delivering a riveting novel of love and betrayal that is deftly and elegantly written.
--Shelf Awareness

The predictable pleasures of a family's holiday implode when two brothers--one brooding, one charming--come to stay. A taut page-turner.
--People Magazine