"[Berlin] has a deep and subtle feeling for the puzzle of Tolstoy's personality, and he writes throughout . . . with a wonderful eloquence."---William Barrett, New York Times
"Beautifully written and suggestive."---W. H. Auden, New Yorker
"A brilliant essay . . . a searching and profound analysis."---E. H. Carr, Times Literary Supplement
"So entertaining, as well as acute, that the reader hardly notices that it is learned too."---Arnold Toynbee, Observer
"The most important study of Tolstoy's thought written in English for a long time."---Noel Annan, Listener
"Berlin's stunning command of the resources of scholarship, his sensitivity to literature and to character, and his eloquence as a writer give this essay the luster of a virtuoso performance."-- "Atlantic"
"Delightful to read."---Peter Calvocoressi, Sunday Times
"Ingenious and subtle."---Max Beloff, Manchester Guardian