When do you have to sacrifice life and limb, time and money, to prevent harm to others? When must you save more people rather than fewer? These questions might arise in emergencies involving strangers drowning or trapped in burning buildings, but they also arise in our everyday lives, in which we confront opportunities to donate time or money to help distant strangers in need of food, shelter, or medical care. With the resources available, we can provide more help--or less.
In The Rules of Rescue, Theron Pummer argues that we are often morally required to engage in effective altruism, directing altruistic efforts in ways that help the most. Even when the personal sacrifice involved makes it morally permissible not to help at all, he contends, it often remains wrong to provide less help rather than more. Using carefully crafted examples, he defends the view that helping distant strangers is more morally akin to rescuing nearby strangers than most of us realize. The ubiquity of opportunities to help distant strangers threatens to make morality extremely demanding, and Pummer argues that it is only thanks to adequate permissions grounded in considerations of cost and autonomy that we may pursue our own plans and projects. He ultimately concludes that many of us are required to provide no less help over our lives than we would have done if we were effective altruists.
Blog of the American Philosophical Association
New Post: Recently Published Book Spotlight: The Rules of Rescue https://t.co/Qe8ec0ibue https://t.co/aJUlIoH5Ue
The program that questions everything—except your intelligence. Sundays 11 am PT on KALW 91.7 FM in SF & worldwide at https://t.co/5yiS132eBu. Subscribe at https://t.co/h9bKeng90I.
This week: Do we have a moral obligation to do the most good we can? Josh & Ray do good by Theron Pummer from @UnivofStAndrews, author of "The Rules of Rescue: Cost, Distance, and #EffectiveAltruism" – Sunday 11a @KALW 91.7 FM in San Francisco & https://t.co/d7JQKNuYas #KALWRadio https://t.co/mh4mhAZuQl
Nigel Warburton is a philosopher.
Just released on the Philosophy Bites podcast: @DavidEdmonds100 interviewing Theron Pummer on the rules of rescue - should appear on Spotify, iTunes etc very soon. You can already listen to it here: https://t.co/fybtke7c8B