. . . meticulously researched and absorbing history . . .
--The Weekly Standard
Tiede has done a superb job of illuminating the Association's early years. But his investigation does more: it instigates further thought. His book should be of interest to anyone trying to come to grips with the role of the professoriate today and with the future of the AAUP.
--Matthew Finkin, University of Illinois, Academe
A volume worth reading as much for its walk-on characters ("distinguished classicist Basil Gildersleeve") as for its discussion of the AAUP's Declaration of Principles.
--Times Higher Education (UK)
Regardless of one's personal perspective on academic freedom and tenure, this book is a must-read for those in higher education programs and administration. It will be enlightening to foes of tenure and refreshing to those who advocate it.
--Choice
Tiede presents a useful history with case studies of the AAUP's early years.
--Academic Quest
Tiede's work will serve as a resource not only for scholars of the history of higher education, but also for researchers and practitioners who seek to gain a long-term historical perspective and context on important topics such as shared governance, academic freedom, tenure, and due process.
--Journal of College and University Law
What we do have now is an excellent story of university reform that includes a thorough exhumation of the compromises and conflicts that were central to the founding and priorities of the AAUP--all of whose principles and liturgy are still invoked a century later.
--Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era
University Reform speaks importantly to our current moment
--New Political Science