"A universal [story] about the ways we connect with the music we adore. By making it personal, and by profiling such a broad spectrum of fans, Rabin puts a human face on what would be caricatures."-- "Publishers Weekly"
"An extremely funny and engaging book about how fandom provides people with surrogate families and a way to escape day-to-day banality."-- "Rolling Stone (four-star review)"
"[A] deftly told tale."-- "The Huffington Post"
"I love this book. Not only is it funny and well written, but it is, dare I say... beautiful. People could learn a thing or two from Nathan. Instead of judging new things and keeping them at bay because they're 'scary' or 'shitty, ' he embraces them and walks away with rich life experiences. So, give yourself a rich life experience of your own and read this book. Then, when you're finished, go and see a Phish show. What do you have to lose? Nothing. What do you have to gain? - maybe they'll play a thirty minute "Tweezer" and you'll get to see god."--Harris Wittels
"Nakedly honest."-- "The Capital Times"
"Awesomely funny.... I've rarely read something that was so good at understanding and building empathy for such an unlikely group."--David Plotz, Slate Staff Pick, Best Books of 2013
"[Insane Clown Posse] may forever remain the butt of jokes, but there's a lot of community-building going on here as revealed in the acclaimed book You Don't Know Me But You Don't Like Me."-- "Huffington Post"