Critic Reviews
Good
Based on 7 reviews on
On the face of it, the three characters in this book seem to have little in common--aside from the fact that each committed wartime acts that led some to see them as national heroes, and others as villains. All three were mythmakers, larger-than-life storytellers, for whom the truth was beside the point. Felix Kersten was a plump Finnish pleasure-seeker who became Heinrich Himmler's indispensable personal masseur--Himmler calling him his "magic Buddha." Kersten presented himself after the war as a resistance hero who convinced Himmler to save countless people from mass murder. Kawashima Yoshiko, a gender-fluid Manchu princess, spied for the Japanese secret police in China, and was mythologized by the Japanese as a heroic combination of Mata Hari and Joan of Arc. Friedrich Weinreb was a Hasidic Jew in Holland who took large amounts of money from fellow Jews in an imaginary scheme to save them from deportation, while in fact betraying some of them to the German secret police. Sentenced after the war as a con artist, he was regarded regarded by supporters as the "Dutch Dreyfus."
All three figures have been vilified and mythologized, out of a never-ending need, Ian Buruma argues, to see history, and particularly war, and above all World War II, as a neat story of angels and devils. The Collaborators is a fascinating reconstruction of what in fact we can know about these incredible figures and what will always remain out of reach. What emerges is all the more mesmerizing for being painted in chiaroscuro. In times of life-and-death stakes, the truth quickly gets buried under lies and self-deception. Now, when demagogues abroad and at home are assaulting the truth once more, the stories of the collaborators and their lessons are indispensable.
All things books from The New York Times. You like reading, we do too.
“What do a Dutch Jewish fixer, a gender-fluid Manchu princess and a lusty Nazi masseur have in common?” writes our reviewer. These three complex, disparate figures feature as central characters in Ian Buruma’s new group biography, “The Collaborators.” https://t.co/rcYbBkBk2k
@lopate_leonard Thursday, May 25, 2023 1 pm WBAI 99.5 FM New York Leonard Lopate’s interviews Ian Buruma on The Collaborators: Three Stories of Deception and Survival in World War II. @PenguinBooks https://t.co/lQXfeJVFUU
Nonpartisan, nonprofit, committed to strong transatlantic ties. #BerlinPrize fellowships awarded to US scholars & artists. Tweets on public program & alumni.
Don’t miss our talk TONIGHT with @bardcollege Prof. of Human Rights & Journalism Ian Buruma! He’ll explore the lives of 3 famous fraudsters featured in his new book — and why such personalities work with criminal regimes and thrive in times of crisis. https://t.co/nRqn1D5Kox
"In The Collaborators, Ian Buruma brings his rare combination of attributes--intelligence, discipline, a commitment to truth (but wariness of certitude), modesty, wisdom, and wit--to revisit the celebrated and clouded sagas of three notorious World War II scoundrels. Their range taps into yet another of Buruma's gifts: his fluency in the cultures and histories of two continents. Telling their tales, disassembling their dissembling, he catalogues the very different set of traits that helped the three survive and even, thanks both to their own lies and the connivance of chroniclers lacking everything Buruma exemplifies, find a measure of rehabilitation they did not deserve." --David Margolick
"Compulsively readable as always, Buruma has taken a riveting subject--collaboration--and delved deep into it, probing concepts of national identity, self-reinvention, loyalty and treason. The Collaborators offers a radical reconsideration of episodes from recent history, while often being unexpectedly entertaining." --Simon Callow
"Buruma sifts through his subjects' complex, multinational backgrounds in fluid prose and brings a welcome measure of sympathy to their lives without minimizing the repercussions of their actions. It's a captivating portrait of what happens when survival turns into self-deception." --Publishers Weekly
"Meticulously, relentlessly, Buruma dissects these collaborators' contradictory and self-serving accounts and cross-references with other sources to get closer to the truth. A powerful exploration of complicity, ambivalence, and the human capacity for deception and self-rationalization." --Library Journal