Critic Reviews
Good
Based on 11 reviews on
"A poignant and piercing examination of the phenomenon of tears--exhaustive, yes, but also open-ended. . . A deeply felt, and genuinely touching, book." --Esmé Weijun Wang, author of The Collected Schizophrenias
"Spellbinding and propulsive--the map of a luminous mind in conversation with books, songs, friends, scientific theories, literary histories, her own jagged joy, and despair. Heather Christle is a visionary writer." --Leni Zumas, author of Red Clocks
This bestselling "lyrical, moving book: part essay, part memoir, part surprising cultural study" is an examination of why we cry, how we cry, and what it means to cry from a woman on the cusp of motherhood confronting her own depression (The New York Times Book Review).
Heather Christle has just lost a dear friend to suicide and now must reckon with her own depression and the birth of her first child. As she faces her grief and impending parenthood, she decides to research the act of crying: what it is and why people do it, even if they rarely talk about it. Along the way, she discovers an artist who designed a frozen-tear-shooting gun and a moth that feeds on the tears of other animals. She researches tear-collecting devices (lachrymatories) and explores the role white women's tears play in racist violence.
Honest, intelligent, rapturous, and surprising, Christle's investigations look through a mosaic of science, history, and her own lived experience to find new ways of understanding life, loss, and mental illness. The Crying Book is a deeply personal tribute to the fascinating strangeness of tears and the unexpected resilience of joy.
one step, one pun, one poem at a time
@CAMONGHNE I think Safia Elhillo’s Home is Not a Country has all that! Also not fiction(s) but maybe The Crying Book by Heather Christle & Draw Your Weapons by Sarah Sentilles & the Empathy Exams by Leslie Jamison. Also maybe see if @mobrowne will slip you an advance copy of IRDBIPTWILTM 😬
Richard Mirabella is a writer and civil servant.
THE CRYING BOOK by Heather Christle was the perfect first read of the year. I'm back in my reading groove. 🥰🥹
Literary non-profit based in #Rochester NY. Promoting reading and writing to all age groups for over 35 years.
Check out some of this week’s new arrivals! - Wild Things, by Laura Kay - Quietly Hostile, by Samantha Irby - The Crying Book, by Heather Christle - Everybody Come Alive, by Marcie Alvis Walker - The Guest, by Emma Cline - Happy Place, by Emily Henry #ampersandbooks https://t.co/3tkxNJQQ04
"[A] lyrical, moving book: part essay, part memoir, part surprising cultural study." --The New York Times Book Review
"[An] indelible book . . . [Christle is] fully aware that tears aren't always to be trusted, even though they can come unbidden and unwanted--the reflexive byproduct of overwhelming emotion. She conveys her beliefs and suspicions in discrete paragraphs of text, quoting lines of poetry, personal correspondence, psychological studies . . . She's drawn to metaphor, even though 'it is dangerous to always think one thing is another.' To insist on anything too permanent is to lay a trap. The kind of metaphor Christle seeks is at once truer and more tenuous." --Jennifer Szalai, The New York Times
"Christle explores the mystery of tears while mining her own sorrows in this intelligent, compelling read." --Kim Hubbard, People
"Poet Heather Christle's book is about more than crying. As she reflects on the loss of a close friend to suicide and her own battle with depression, Christle asks why and how we cry and what it means, especially for women, to do so. But in The Crying Book, the author's blend of personal experience and scientific research gives way to broader discussions about motherhood, mental health, grief and art." --Annabel Gutterman, Time
"Invigorating . . . Unique and inspired . . . 'They say perhaps we cry when language fails, when words can no longer adequately convey our hurt, ' Christle muses. But with The Crying Book, language hasn't failed. Precisely the opposite. She's used her gifts as a poet to get at the heart of why sadness arrives and how it affects us." --Alexis Burling, San Francisco Chronicle
"The book's effects are sly and cumulative, relying not so much on any one observation as on associations, echoes, contrasts--a method that reflects Christle's view of art and life, the interdependence, the complex contagion and repetition of feeling and action and reaction that marks them . . . It's about grief and friendship, but only delicately so. Christle wants to preserve the particularity of experiences while illuminating what they have in common. Again and again she emphasizes that separation: 'It is dangerous, ' she insists, 'to always think one thing is another, every event a metaphor for another.' This is also to say that writing itself is dangerous, as well as essential." --Lidija Haas, Harper's Magazine
"Christle is a poet, and her prose shows it. You will surely end the book knowing much more about tears than when you started . . . Christle invites us into her sadness and along the way manages to unlock the beauty within." --Jonathan Foiles, Psychology Today
"Heather Christle's new book is a combination of personal musings about depression, childbirth, and motherhood, and fascinating researched tidbits about crying--its history, its use in literature and pop culture, its politics, and the science behind it all. Basically, it's Maggie Nelson's Bluets, but about crying, and it's every bit as dazzling as the stars that dot its cover." --Cristina Arreola, Bustle
"The Crying Book is a roving history, spanning a remarkable cast of grief experts showcased in wide-ranging vignettes . . . With a poet's touch, gentle and delightfully promiscuous, Christle moves fluidly across disparate disciplines and between her sources' professional and personal lives." --Fathima Calder, Guernica
"Yes, this is a whole book on crying, and it's sad and also beautiful . . . It's a gorgeous book. Everything from the cover to the ideas to the sentences is moving and sometimes, in spite of what you might expect given the subject matter, comforting. Readers who like the fragmentary style of Sarah Manguso and Maggie Nelson will want to get a copy." --Rebecca Hussey, Book Riot
"An eclectic reflection on human waterworks . . . The unconventional format, combined with the author's vast survey of the topic, provides fascinating food for thought. A surprisingly hopeful meditation on why we shed tears." --Kirkus Reviews
"Readers are sure to be moved to tears themselves. This is a lovely meditation on life and death through the lens of tears, both those spurred by grief and those by joy." --Booklist
"In The Crying Book, Heather Christle makes a poignant and piercing examination of the phenomenon of tears--exhaustive, yes, but also open-ended, such that I was left clutching this book to my chest with wonder, asking myself when the last time was that I cried, and why. A deeply felt, and genuinely touching, book." --Esmé Weijun Wang, author of The Collected Schizophrenias