Critic Reviews
Good
Based on 9 reviews on
"Enthralling ... captivating reading." --The New York Times Book Review
At the end of World War II, the United States was considered the victor over tyranny and a champion of freedom. But it was clear--to some--that the Soviet Union was already seeking to expand and foment revolution around the world, and the American government's strategy in response relied on the secret efforts of a newly formed CIA. Chronicling the fascinating lives of four agents, Scott Anderson follows the exploits of four spies: Michael Burke, who organized parachute commandos from an Italian villa; Frank Wisner, an ingenious spymaster who directed actions around the world; Peter Sichel, a German Jew who outwitted the ruthless KGB in Berlin; and Edward Lansdale, a mastermind of psychological warfare in the Far East. But despite their lofty ambitions, time and again their efforts went awry, thwarted by a combination of ham-fisted politicking and ideological rigidity at the highest levels of the government.
"It’s a deep dive into the beginning of American espionage while being an intimate portrait of individuals. It’s macro and micro at once—each illuminating the other. Simultaneously fascinating, jaw-dropping and tragic."
Peter Baker is a journalist for the New York Times.
Two new books I didn't get to this year but are first up in 2021 are "The Quiet Americans" by Scott Anderson and "The Zealot and the Emancipator" by @hwbrands, two of the best writers out there. https://t.co/5KjCCOwVoS https://t.co/rMT3pHJkG2
Where great minds meet. Subscribe to #IntelligenceSquared+ today
Spies, Communism and the Cold War A look back at when Scott Anderson joined us to discuss his book 'The Quiet Americans' chronicling the exploits of four American spies, with journalist Hugo Lindgren. https://t.co/3Zite6vfdu
"A DARKLY ENTERTAINING tale about American espionage, set in an era when Washington's fear and skepticism about the agency resembles our climate today."
--The New York Times
"In his skillful and fascinating "The Quiet Americans"...Mr. Anderson ingeniously tells his story through the entwined sagas of four of the secret service's most adept and intrepid operatives"
--Wall Street Journal
"This intriguing book is an indictment. From its first page it argues that the CIA lost its way, in all senses, in the first decade of the cold war. Its witnesses are four courageous and initially idealistic patriots. Frank Wisner oversaw some of the earliest efforts to "roll back" communism in Europe. Michael Burke was a daredevil figure in the same game. Edward Lansdale was an éminence grise in the Far East. Peter Sichel, a German-born Jewish wine-merchant and Wunderkind--and the only one of the four still alive--held his nose as he co-opted former Nazis into the agency, an initiative cited as one of its original sins....Many of the CIA's failures stemmed from familiar shortcomings. 'We all have this tendency to look for information that confirms our beliefs and to ignore what conflicts with them," explains Mr Sichel. "It's very hard to give somebody information he doesn't want to hear, and the more senior they are, the worse it is.'
--The Economist
"In this sweeping, vivid, beautifully observed book, Scott Anderson unearths the devastating secret history of how the Unites States lost the plot during the Cold War. By focusing on the twisty, colorful lives of four legendary spies, Anderson distills the larger geopolitical saga into an intimate story of flawed but talented men, of the 'disease of empires, ' and of the inescapable moral hazard of American idealism and power. It's a hell of a book, with themes about the unintended consequences of espionage and interventionism that still resonate, powerfully, today."
--Patrick Radden Keefe, author of SAY NOTHING
"[A] highly entertaining history of four Cold War spies..."
--Evan Thomas, Air Mail
"Anderson delivers a complex, massively scaled narrative, balancing prodigious research with riveting storytelling skills...Over the course of the narrative, the author amply shows how the CIA was increasingly pushed to function as an instrument of politically charged ambitions. An engrossing history of the early days of the CIA."
--Kirkus Reviews (Starred)
"Anderson notes the harrowing emotional cost on his subjects...as the U.S. threw its support behind autocratic leaders and missed opportunities to aid legitimate liberation movements such as the 1956 Hungarian revolution. Such blunders, Anderson writes, recast the U.S. from WWII savior to "one more empire in the mold of all those that had come before." Laced with vivid character sketches and vital insights into 20th-century geopolitics, this stand-out chronicle helps to make sense of the world today."
--Publishers Weekly (Starred)
"Anderson weaves his narrative among the lives of his subjects, highlighting aspects of their livelihoods as American spies that were at times equally frustrating, ridiculous, and chillingly dangerous...A fascinating and compulsively readable account of wartime spying."
--Library Journal