"Brilliant in execution and hysterical in dialogue; Shea's pretty great, too."--Kirkus Reviews
"Shea's cleverly written tale makes this a standout, but there's substance here, too.... Will delight unicorn fans and perhaps create new fans for goats.--Booklist
"A great study in grass-is-greener envy management and a nonstop giggle generator." --Publishers Weekly
"Shea's honest portrayal of negative emotions mixed with offbeat comedy should make this a winner."--Horn Book
"Shea's cartoon illustrations are perfectly suited to expressing the characters' varied emotions while keeping the story very tongue-in-cheek, with lots of giggle-worthy details. An ideal choice for fans of silliness."--School Library Journal