Critic Reviews
Good
Based on 8 reviews on
Histories of music overwhelmingly suppress stories of the outsiders and rebels who created musical revolutions and instead celebrate the mainstream assimilators who borrowed innovations, diluted their impact, and disguised their sources. In Music: A Subversive History, Ted Gioia reclaims the story of music for the riffraff, insurgents, and provocateurs.
Gioia tells a four-thousand-year history of music as a global source of power, change, and upheaval. He shows how outcasts, immigrants, slaves, and others at the margins of society have repeatedly served as trailblazers of musical expression, reinventing our most cherished songs from ancient times all the way to the jazz, reggae, and hip-hop sounds of the current day.
Music: A Subversive History is essential reading for anyone interested in the meaning of music, from Sappho to the Sex Pistols to Spotify.
Matthew Yglesias is a blogger and journalist.
Ted Gioia says it's not just that I am getting old, new music is becoming less popular in general relative to old music. He blames various forms of industry short-sightedness and blundering for this. https://t.co/LOMnxEBe2f
Here & Now is a news and culture program from NPR and WBUR.
In the last year, the music industry spent $5 billion buying the rights to old songs — but only a fraction of that went toward new artists, music writer Ted Gioia says. https://t.co/2BCdDQlNkG
by day: economics of science @dartmouth, prev. research in neuro | by night: composer | Measure for measure on YT | Emergent Ventures '22
revisiting Ted Gioia’s Music: A subversive history, and the opening of the first chapter, "The origin of music as a force of creative destruction", contains an apt suggestion to rename the Big Bang https://t.co/IvwbO8TyXK
"In describing the kinds of music that existed throughout history, [Gioia] treats topics that have long been suppressed or ignored by historians who crave respectability, topics such as magic, sexuality, and violence. . . . As a writer and thinker he is compelling and thought provoking."
--Choice"Gioia takes a look at the underside of music history, teasing out the episodes of sex, violence, and rebellion out of which music developed."
--No Depression"Invigorating."
--Pop Matters"Marvelous."
--Marc Myers, Jazz Wax"Essential."
--Jacksonville Journal-Courier"Music is Gioia's magnum opus, an inventive and original work that spans 4,000 years. . . . Throughout this vital book, Gioia shows that music is still a disruptive force."
--DownBeat"[Gioia] uses the familiar scheme of cyclical rejuvenation through transformation as a mechanism to consider the whole history of music, from the sounds of the primordial world to electronic dance music today, in his latest and most ambitious book. . . . Smart but readable."
--New York Times Book Review"In carefully examining its 'subversive' side . . . Ted Gioia does much to convince us that music, far from being incidental to deeper political purposes or a convenient index of popular taste, is a profound 'force of transformation and enchantment, ' intrinsic to human society."
--New Criterion"Gioia asserts that music history generally shares the whitewashed stories of the assimilators. . . . Exhaustively researched."
--Christian Science Monitor"Mr. Gioia's alternative history of music is extraordinary, groundbreaking, and bone-chillingly real."
--Washington Times"There is so much rich history in this book; so many interesting and startling facts and stories."
--Syncopated Times