Critic Reviews
Good
Based on 4 reviews on
In The Aristocracy of Talent, esteemed journalist and historian Adrian Wooldridge traces the history of meritocracy forged by the politicians and officials who introduced the revolutionary principle of open competition, the psychologists who devised methods for measuring natural mental abilities, and the educationalists who built ladders of educational opportunity. He looks outside western cultures and shows what transformative effects it has had everywhere it has been adopted, especially once women were brought into the meritocratic system.
Wooldridge also shows how meritocracy has now become corrupted and argues that the recent stalling of social mobility is the result of failure to complete the meritocratic revolution. Rather than abandoning meritocracy, he says, we should call for its renewal.
@Columbia/@GC_CUNY | Philosophy/Mathematics “Out of the crooked timber of humanity, no straight thing was ever made.” ━ Immanuel Kant
"The Aristocracy of Talent: How Meritocracy Made the Modern World" by Adrian Wooldridge, review — Does meritocracy work? This history argues that hard work is as key to success as intelligence. https://t.co/fm4KPYFTUB https://t.co/MiIMTruCah
Technology and business editor for The Economist
Enjoyed brilliant book on flaws of meritocracy "The Aristocracy of Talent" by @adwooldridge Now turning to "Tyranny of Merit"/ Michel Sandel. Does it bother intelligentsia that they're just talking to their clever selves? Can the "poorly educated" use the critiques to get CHANGE?
Host of the the CBS Eye on the World with John Batchelor; novelist as John Calvin Batchelor. Above: MidSummer gardening with Gladiolas & Lillies opening.
8/8: The Meritocratic Sunak Government in turmoil: The Aristocracy of Talent: How Meritocracy Made the Modern World, by Adrian Wooldridge https://t.co/Q6LDN3WjMg via @Audioboom
"Unfailingly entertaining, effortlessly drawing on a wealth of anecdote and statistics." --Times Literary Supplement
"This unique and fascinating history explains why the blame now being piled upon meritocracy is misplaced--and that assigning responsibilities to the people best able to discharge them really is better than the time-honored customs of corruption, patronage, nepotism, and hereditary castes. Wooldridge upends many common assumptions and provides an indispensable back story to this fraught and pressing issue."--Steven Pinker, Johnstone Family Professor of Psychology at Harvard University
"Wonderful...The Aristocracy of Talent provides an important and needed corrective to contemporary critiques of meritocracy. It puts meritocracy in an illuminating historical and cross-cultural perspective that shows how critical the judgment of people by their talents rather than their bloodlines or connections has been to creating the modern world. Highly recommended."
--Francis Fukuyama, Senior Fellow at Stanford University's Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies
"This is an important, fascinating and superbly written book. The Aristocracy of Talent pulls the rug out from under the current assault on meritocracy. How quickly we forget that reformers struggled for centuries to displace privilege of birth with merit-based judgments. Rejecting merit in favor of equal outcomes, Adrian Wooldridge persuasively argues, is like handing the keys of the future to China and other cultures focused on results. Does the assault on core values leave you at a loss for words? Read this book."
--Philip K Howard, author of The Death of Common Sense and founder of Common Good
"Wooldridge... makes intelligent contributions to the fraught cultural debate about the value--or lack thereof--of meritocracy." --Brooke Allen, The Hudson Review