Critic Reviews
Good
Based on 12 reviews on
In our culture, the Bible is monolithic: It is a collection of books that has been unchanged and unchallenged since the earliest days of the Christian church. The idea of the Bible as "Holy Scripture," a non-negotiable authority straight from God, has prevailed in Western society for some time. And while it provides a firm foundation for centuries of Christian teaching, it denies the depth, variety, and richness of this fascinating text. In A History of the Bible, John Barton argues that the Bible is not a prescription to a complete, fixed religious system, but rather a product of a long and intriguing process, which has inspired Judaism and Christianity, but still does not describe the whole of either religion. Barton shows how the Bible is indeed an important source of religious insight for Jews and Christians alike, yet argues that it must be read in its historical context--from its beginnings in myth and folklore to its many interpretations throughout the centuries.
It is a book full of narratives, laws, proverbs, prophecies, poems, and letters, each with their own character and origin stories. Barton explains how and by whom these disparate pieces were written, how they were canonized (and which ones weren't), and how they were assembled, disseminated, and interpreted around the world--and, importantly, to what effect. Ultimately, A History of the Bible argues that a thorough understanding of the history and context of its writing encourages religious communities to move away from the Bible's literal wording--which is impossible to determine--and focus instead on the broader meanings of scripture.
Senior Fellow, @trinityforum. Writing for @nytimes & @TheAtlantic. Worked in Reagan/Bush41 administrations and Bush43 White House. Author, THE DEATH OF POLITICS
A question for @mbird12 and @UnbelievableJB (and others): Have you read John Barton's A History of the Bible; and, if so, what'd you make of it? It was widely praised for its scholarship, rightly so, but also (predictably) controversial in parts of the evangelical world. Thanks.
Renowned publisher of serious nonfiction by leading intellectuals, scholars, and journalists. An imprint of @hachetteUS
Happy Pub Day to THE WORD! 🎉 From distinguished Oxford scholar and the author of A History of the Bible, John Barton, THE WORD examines how biblical translation works and why it matters. Learn more: https://t.co/9Fzd8vQtc8 https://t.co/RcMJXsnn3l
Writer, Seeker, Co-Leader of The Ordinary Office. 'Challenging Theologian of our Time'. Striving to be an Ally to all who need. All opinions shared are my own.
Interesting blog reflection for this morning. John Barton 'A History of the Bible' is an excellent text to explore more. https://t.co/M2dmv9yfvB
Praise for A History of the Bible
"In addition to laying out the historical contexts in which the Old and the New Testaments were created, this stimulating study considers how they have been read, taught, and lived by believers...[Barton] proposes a nuanced approach that seeks to give the Bible its due without asking too much of it." --The New Yorker
"A History of the Bible is a lucidly written distillation of a vast array of scholarship." --Wall Street Journal
"A supple and intelligent recap of the Holy Scriptures, their origins and contexts, [and] their meaning in a broad historical sense" --Lit Hub
"Immensely impressive...A HISTORY OF THE BIBLE is a confident, distinctly courteous performance, wary of overstatement and sure of its intellectual footing. No work of literature has a more fascinating life story than the Bible, and Barton has told it with a precision and insight that will make this the definitive account of the century." -- Christian Science Monitor
"John Barton has written a wise and eminently sane book about a book which has inspired both insanity and wisdom. It is a landmark in the field, and it will do great good." -- Diarmaid MacCulloch
"John Barton's new book gives a superb overview... condensing masses of research into an easily accessible volume for the non-specialist ... even for those deeply familiar with the Bible there is much here to be learnt." -- Bart D Ehrman, author of The Triumph of Christianity: How a Forbidden Religion Swept the World
"With emotional and psychological insight, Barton unlocks this sleeping giant of our culture for the untrained but curious general reader... He has produced a masterpiece." -- Peter Stanford, Sunday Times
"This strikingly accessible yet wonderfully erudite volume will be welcomed by many ... a tour de force." -- BBC History Magazine
"Barton is extremely good at untangling what is actually known from what can be reasonably inferred from what has been lost to time...his book will have much to tell both curious secular readers and the faithful about the patchwork process by which a compilation that is so often treated monolithically came to exist." -- Harper's Magazine
"Barton's rigorous, accessible history will appeal to academics and general readers alike." -- Publishers Weekly, starred review